GNN - Genome News Network  
  Home | About | Topics
Whose Genome Is It Anyway?
By Barbara J. Culliton

One of the questions that comes to mind when researchers report sequencing the human genome is this: Whose Genome Is It Anyway? The answer turns out to be that it doesn't really matter. As scientists long suspected, human beings are all very much alike when it comes to our genes. As reported in the February 16th issue of Science (released today), Celera data suggest that the DNA of human beings is 99.9 percent alike—a powerful statement about the relatedness of all humankind. This relatedness is reflected beautifully in Science's striking cover.

To sequence the genome, scientists at Celera Genomics used DNA from five individuals of varying ethnicity, and also included data compiled by the publicly funded Human Genome Project. The five people whose genomes were used in sequencing came from a pool of 21 donors, who were accepted according to rigorous criteria for informed consent. Celera created an Institutional Review Board (IRB) that developed a set of procedures that strictly adhere to the requirements the United States government has established for any research on human beings or their blood and other tissues. One of the very first things the members of the IRB agreed is that the identity of the men and women who donated DNA samples for sequencing must not be revealed. Donors were promised that their names would never be made public. A careful system for coding samples means that even within Celera itself, the donors' privacy is secure.

Therefore, one of the most asked questions about sequencing: "Whose genome is it anyway?" cannot be answered. What can be said is that five donors were selected from a pool of up to 30 individuals who volunteered because they knew about the program, responded to newspaper ads, or reacted favorably to outreach efforts to ensure ethnic diversity. Harold P. Freeman, M.D., a member of Celera's IRB, wrote the following prologue to the protocol to speak to the very important matter of diversity.

Mapping the DNA sequence variation in the human genome holds the potential for promoting the fundamental unity of all humankind. Throughout recorded history and up to the present time, countless human conflicts have occurred based on how groups of people have seen, classified and behaved toward another group.

Popular conceptualizations of race date back several centuries and are rooted in 19th and early 20th century scientific thought. In the past, some scientists used observations of racial differences to support racist doctrines. Racism, rooted in the erroneous concept of biological racial superiority, has powerful societal effects and continues to influence science.

Race as used in the United States is a social and political construct derived from our nation's history. It has no basis in science. The biologic concept of race is now believed to be untenable.

The power of science can be used to eliminate public perceptions of racial superiority and inferiority, which are the basis of racism itself. In this way, the mapping of the human genome could be pivotal in promoting the concept of one race, the human race.

Members of the Institutional Review Board

Paul Calabresi, M.D., Chair
Dr. Calabresi, an internationally recognized authority on the pharmacology of anti-cancer agents, was appointed Director of Brown-Tufts Cancer Center in November, 1997, and is currently Professor of Medicine and Chairman Emeritus of the Department of Medicine at Brown University School of Medicine and Director of the Division of Clinical Pharmacology at Rhode Island Hospital. He is a Clinical Professor of Medicine at Tufts University. He serves on the President's Cancer Panel and is a former chairman of the National Cancer Advisory Board. Dr. Calabresi is a member of the National Institute of Medicine of the National Academy of Sciences.

Arthur L. Caplan, Ph.D.
Dr. Caplan, a leading authority on ethical issues surrounding research in the biomedical sciences, is Director of the Center for Bioethics, University of Pennsylvania Health System, and Chairman of the Advisory Committee to the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, and the Food and Drug Administration on Blood Safety and Availability.

Michele K. Evans, M.D.
Dr. Evans, a physician-scientist who is an active spokesperson for women and minority scientists, is currently Deputy Scientific Director for the Intramural Research Progam of the National Institutes on Aging, National Institutes of Health.

Harold P. Freeman, M.D.
Dr. Freeman, a leading authority on the inter-relationships between race, poverty and cancer, is President, CEO and Director of Surgery at North General Hospital in New York City. He is currently Chairman of the President's Cancer Panel and has served as President of the American Cancer Society. Dr. Freeman is the former Director of Surgery at Columbia University and is Chairman of the New York State Breast Cancer Treatment Quality Advisory Panel. He is a member of the Institute of Medicine of the National Academy of Sciences.

Judith E. Karp, M.D.
A board-certified oncologist, Dr. Karp is an authority on the molecular mechanisms of leukemias and lymphomas. She is currently Professor of Hematology, University of Maryland Cancer Center in Baltimore, MD.

Brad Margus
Mr. Margus is an articulate patient advocate for people concerned about Ataxia Telangiectasia, a rare genetic syndrome. He is President of the AT Children's Project at Deerfield Beach, FL. He is a national speaker and fund raiser for the AT Children's Project.

Charles P. McCarthy, Ph.D.
Dr. McCarthy, a well-known authority on the ethics of human research, is a Senior Research Fellow, Kennedy Institute of Ethics, at Georgetown University, Washington, D.C. He is the former Director of the Office for the Protection from Research Risks, National Institutes of Health, and is a member of the Board of Directors of Public Responsibility in Medicine and Research. He is a charter member of the Board of the Association for the Accreditation of Human Research Protection Programs.

Gerald D. Rogell, M.D., P.A.
A board-certified ophthalmologist, Dr. Rogell is the Senior Attending Physician at the Washington Hospital Center and Assistant Clinical Professor at Georgetown University Hospital. He is a leading authority on diseases of the retina and an expert on laser treatment of diabetic retinopathy.

. . .

Back to GNN Home Page